How do you write a response to reviewers example?
Response: Agree. I/We have, accordingly, done/revised/changed/modified…..to emphasize this point. [Discuss the changes made, providing the necessary explanation/clarification. Mention exactly where in the revised manuscript this change can be found – page number, paragraph, and line.]
What is the main purpose of peer review?
Peer review is designed to assess the validity, quality and often the originality of articles for publication. Its ultimate purpose is to maintain the integrity of science by filtering out invalid or poor quality articles.
How long is peer review process?
How do you respond to reviewer comments the calm way?
How to respond to reviewer comments – the CALM way
- C: Comprehend (keep your cool!) When the decision letter arrives, read over the comments…Take time to understand the reviewers’ feedback and consider what they are asking you to do.
- A: Answer (amend or advocate!)
- L: List (make a list…
- M: Mindful (make it easy for the editor – they will appreciate it!)
What do peer reviewers look for?
Reviewers look for accuracy, timeliness, and appropriateness of the manuscript that can greatly affect the chances of publishing your research. Apart from these, reviewers check for the scientific merits of the manuscript, its methods, and research misconduct (if any).
What are three benefits of peer review?
Advantages include: Establishes the validity of research based upon the expert knowledge of other researchers in the discipline, therefore preventing falsified work from being accepted within an area of study. Provides valuable feedback so that researchers can revise and improve their papers before publication.
What are the steps of the peer review process?
The peer review process
- Step 1: Editor assessment. download PDF.
- Step 2: First round of peer review. The editor will then find and contact other researchers who are experts in your field, asking them to review the paper.
- Step 3: Revise and resubmit.
- Step 4: Accepted.
How do you say thank you for the photographer?
#10 We just want to say how pleased we are with the results of your photography. You were able to execute the session with warmth and kindness and yet still be attentive to detail. You are officially our favorite photographer, and we will not hesitate to use you again in the future. Thank you so much!
Do compilations require peer review?
Interpretation — Yes. If a firm elects to enroll in the peer review program, and its only level of service is performing management use only compilation engagements, it is required to have a peer review. The peer review is required to be performed under these standards.
How reliable is peer review?
Some reviewers did not spot any, and most reviewers spotted only about a quarter. Peer review sometimes picks up fraud by chance, but generally it is not a reliable method for detecting fraud because it works on trust.
How do you thank an editor?
Explanatory “Thank the Editor” Notes
- Identify the payment, issue, and your piece by name.
- Specify the reasons for your thanks.
- Compliment something else in the issue, preferably something by the editor.
- Jump on the bandwagon.
How much does peer review cost?
A $65 annual AICPA PRIMA-user fee is charged to firms enrolled in a non-AICPA peer review program….Annual Administrative Fees.
|Administrative Fee Structure||AICPA or FICPA Member Firm*||Non-Member **Firm Includes $100 Non-member Fee|
How do you respond to a journal editor?
Read, calm down, reflect, wait a day or two before responding, get author input. Always thank the editor and reviewers • Reviewers are asking questions so that the answers can help improve the manuscript. Authors must also add changes to the manuscript.
Do peer reviewers get paid?
A vital, and often overlooked, aspect of peer review is that in the current system, peer reviewers are normally not paid for their work. They are, instead, rewarded non-financially by means of acknowledgment in journals, positions on editorial boards, free journal access, discounts on author fees, etc.
How do you deal with a bad peer review?
Regarding responding to the harsh or negative peer reviewer comments, you should deal with them as you would deal with any other comment. Give a point-by-point response to the comments, mentioning whether you agree or disagree with them. If you disagree with some of the comments, provide your reasons for doing so.
How much do reviewers get paid?
|U.S. Bank Reviewer salaries – 3 salaries reported||$45,553/yr|
|Discover Ready Reviewer salaries – 2 salaries reported||$27/hr|
|Udacity Reviewer salaries – 2 salaries reported||$5/hr|
|Google Reviewer salaries – 2 salaries reported||$54,324/yr|
Are prepared financial statements subject to peer review?
For firms already enrolled in the Program, engagements to prepare financial statements would fall within the scope of peer review. You should check with the SBOA(s) where you perform such engagements to determine whether you need to enroll in peer review.
What is the first step in an effective peer review?
The best way to structure your review is to: Open your review with the most important comments—a summarization of the research and your impression of the research. Make sure to include feedback on the strengths, as well as the weaknesses, of the manuscript.
How do you write a response to a review?
How to respond to a positive review (4 steps)
- Step 1: Thank the customer for the positive review and be specific.
- Step 2: Use the business name and keywords in your review response to the good review.
- Step 3: Add a little marketing to your review response.
- Step 4: Invite customer to do something in your response.
How do you handle reviewer comments?
7 tips for dealing with reviewer comments
- Use the reviewer comments even if your paper is rejected.
- Be polite – but not over-polite.
- Don’t feel obliged to accept everything the reviewer says.
- What to do when two reviewers ask for opposite things.
- Make sure you address everything.
- Dealing with comments you don’t understand.
- Engage the editor as an adjudicator.
How do you thank an editor for accepting articles?
I appreciate your acceptance of my paper for publication in the World Journal of Gastroenterology. I thank you for the valuable comments on this paper and have made the following adjustments accordingly. Reviewer #1 The manuscript is quite well written.
How do you compliment an editor?
Tell the reader that you enjoyed or appreciated his or her work. State specifically what you liked about the reader’s work. Close by thanking the writer for his or her work.
How effective is peer review?
Peer review is perceived as one of the mainstays of scientific publishing. Papers that undergo the peer review process are generally considered to be of high quality since they are scrutinized by experts before publication.
What do I write in a review?
Table of contents
- Provide useful, constructive feedback.
- Talk about a range of elements, including customer service.
- Be detailed, specific, and honest.
- Leave out links and personal information.
- Keep it civil and friendly.
- Feel free to update your review if needed.
- Check you’ve got the right domain name or company.
How do you write a peer review?
- Summary of the research and your overall impression. In your own words, summarize what the manuscript claims to report.
- Discussion of specific areas for improvement.
- Any other points.
- General guidelines for effective feedback.
How do you respond to a journal acceptance?
You can write to the editor thanking him for considering your paper for publication. In the same letter, add a word of thanks for the reviewers as well, for their valuable comments on your paper. It is indeed a thoughtful gesture on your part, and I’m sure the editor and peer reviewers will appreciate it.
How do you write a response?
Writing a Response or Reaction Paper
- Identify the author and title of the work and include in parentheses the publisher and publication date.
- Write an informative summary of the material.
- Condense the content of the work by highlighting its main points and key supporting points.
- Use direct quotations from the work to illustrate important ideas.